Four Firms, Three Goals
DALAL ST. · FY21 → FY26

Economics group project · Revenue, cost and profit

OPENING BELL 09:15 IST · SESSION FY21 → FY26

Four Indian firms. Three ways to chase profit.

We followed Eternal, Paytm, ITC and Mahindra & Mahindra through six financial years, FY2020-21 to FY2025-26, to see how real companies maximise revenue, cut costs and earn profit.

Presented by Attharv Jain Team Attharv Jain · Pranav Goel · Aaryan Manchnda · Anmol Gaur · Divyansh Verma

→Space next chapter · F full screen

Net profit margin, FY21 → FY26

All four ended FY26 more profitable than FY21, by four different routes

Consolidated accounts, %. ITC’s FY25 spike is a one-off ₹15,129 cr demerger gain. Hover the chart to read each year.

09:15 IST · Opening bell · The three objectives

Every firm here moved one side of a single equation.

Profit=Total revenue−Total cost

Goal 1 · Revenue maximisation

Baumol’s model

MR = 0 profit floor output →

Managers push sales as high as possible, as long as profit stays above a minimum owners accept. With no floor, output rises until marginal revenue reaches zero.

In the accounts: very fast sales growth, thin margins, heavy spending to win market share.

Our case: Eternal

Goal 2 · Cost minimisation

Least-cost production

lowest cost AC output →

Make the chosen output at the lowest possible cost: the cheapest mix of inputs, with waste (X-inefficiency) removed.

In the accounts: costs falling, fewer staff, less marketing; losses shrink even when sales fall.

Our case: Paytm

Goal 3 · Profit maximisation

MR = MC

MR = MC MRMC output →

Choose the output where marginal revenue equals marginal cost. Each extra sale is judged by the profit it adds, not by how much turnover it brings.

In the accounts: profit growing faster than revenue, rising margins, pricing power, a richer mix.

Our cases: ITC, and M&M’s costs

EternalZomato · Blinkit

Sales rose 27-fold in five years, but profit stayed thin.

NSE: ETERNAL▲ Sales 27.3×▼ FY26 net profit −31%
Revenue maximisation
27.3×

Sales turnover, ₹1,994 cr (FY21) → ₹54,364 cr (FY26), or 93.7% a year

₹366 cr
FY26 net profit, down 31%
0.7%
FY26 net margin: under ₹1 kept per ₹100 of sales

Bear case · caveatAbout ₹25,073 cr of FY26 sales is an accounting change: Blinkit now books the full price of goods it sells. Without it, sales still grew about 14.7×, or about 71% a year.

Sales turnover, ₹ crore

Consolidated · Blinkit included from 10 August 2022

SalesFY26 Blinkit accounting change (about ₹25,073 cr)

Why · scale

Buying and scaling Blinkit

Bought in August 2022 in a ₹4,447.5 cr all-share deal. Dark stores (delivery-only mini-warehouses) grew from 377 in March 2023 to 2,243 in March 2026.

Orders: 203 mn (FY24) → 917 mn (FY26)

Why · market share

Spending to win customers

Gold members got free delivery above ₹199, later ₹99. Customer delivery fees fell from ₹1,614 cr (FY23) to ₹875 cr (FY26): a deliberate price cut to lift volume.

Ads and promotion: 9.7% → 11.4% of sales*

Why · profit floor

An interest cushion

The IPO (₹9,000 cr) and a 2024 share placement (₹8,500 cr) left cash earning interest. Other income reached ₹1,396 cr in FY26.

Without it: a ₹781 cr pre-tax loss in FY26

The economics

Baumol fits: no promoter group, so managers chase sales once a profit floor is met. Most of the FY26 jump is accounting, and food delivery (₹2,079 cr segment profit) behaves like a profit maximiser.

Fit: good but imperfect

* FY26 share excludes the Blinkit accounting change. Source: Eternal audited results, shareholders’ letters FY22–FY26, Annual Report FY26.

PaytmOne 97 Communications

Costs fell by over a quarter in two years, and Paytm made its first full-year profit.

NSE: PAYTM▼ Total costs −26.8%▲ Net profit ₹552 cr
Cost minimisation
−26.8%

Total costs, ₹11,645 cr (FY24) → ₹8,521 cr (FY26), while the value of payments handled rose 30%

₹552 cr
FY26 net profit, Paytm’s first full-year profit
−₹1,701 cr
FY21 net loss

Bear case · caveat41% of the cut was a non-cash fall in stock-option (ESOP) cost. Total costs still exceeded sales in FY26, so the profit relied on ₹854 cr of other income, mostly interest.

Where the ₹3,124 cr cost cut came from

FY24 → FY26, ₹ crore. No cost line rose.

Non-cashCash cuts (about 30%)Volume-linked and other

Why · accounting

The founder gave up his stock options

ESOP cost fell 88% over FY24–FY26, mostly because Vijay Shekhar Sharma surrendered 2.1 crore options in April 2025 after SEBI scrutiny.

An accounting saving, not fewer real resources

Why · shock

The RBI action shrank volume

The RBI’s January 2024 action ended wallet and FASTag revenue. Processing fees stayed at 52.6% of payment revenue in FY24, FY25 and FY26.

Fees fell with volume, not efficiency

Why · efficiency

Real cuts in staff and marketing

Non-sales staff fell 31% while sales staff rose 18%. Marketing and cashback fell from 13.5% to 6.4% of sales (FY23 → FY26).

About 30% of the saving was cash efficiency

The economics

Least-cost production, and Leibenstein’s X-inefficiency: slack built up in the cash-rich years after the 2021 IPO. Over five years, though, costs rose 78% as sales tripled.

Fit: good for FY24–FY26 only

Source: Paytm annual reports FY22–FY26, earnings releases Q4 FY24 and Q4 FY26, RBI press release (16 Feb 2024).

ITCCigarettes, FMCG, paper, agri

In FY24 sales were flat, yet profit rose 6.5%.

NSE: ITC▲ FY24 net profit +6.5%▼ FY24 sales −0.1%
Profit up, revenue stalls
+6.5%

Net profit growth in FY24, on like-for-like sales growth of −0.1%

4.1%
Profit growth without a one-off ₹468 cr tax credit
+2.3%
FY24 operating profit (EBITDA) growth on flat sales

Bear case · caveatsHotels was demerged on 1 January 2025, so FY25–FY26 exclude it. FY25’s reported ₹35,052 cr profit includes a ₹15,129 cr non-cash demerger gain; the underlying figure is ₹20,036 cr.

FY24: agri lost ₹2,319 cr of sales but only ₹102 cr of profit

Change in segment revenue and segment profit (PBIT), FY23 → FY24, ₹ crore

Change in revenueChange in profit

Why · policy

Export bans cut low-margin trade

India banned wheat exports (May 2022) and non-basmati white rice exports (July 2023), shrinking ITC’s farm-commodity trading.

Agri earns only about 7 paise per rupee of sales

Why · pricing power

Cigarette demand barely reacts to price

Volumes grew only about 3% in FY24 (ICICI Direct estimate), but net cigarette revenue grew about 7–8%: higher prices and a richer mix.

Habit-forming, so demand is price-inelastic

Why · mix

Cigarettes carry the profit

In FY21–FY26 cigarettes earned 75–83% of segment profit from just 37–41% of gross segment revenue.

Profit ≈ 72% of net revenue, vs about 7% for agri

The economics

MR = MC: dropping agri trades where marginal revenue barely beat marginal cost cost little profit. Over five years the EBITDA margin barely moved, 34.5% in FY21 and 34.6% in FY26.

Fit: strong in FY24, weaker over five years

Cigarette profit share of net revenue is an estimate. Source: ITC consolidated results FY24–FY26 with segment information; ICICI Direct Q4FY25 update.

Mahindra & MahindraSUVs, tractors, finance

Profit rose 12-fold, while the operating margin stayed flat.

NSE: M&M▲ Net profit 12.3×▬ EBITDA margin 18.4% → 18.6%
Costs falling unevenly
12.3×

Net profit, ₹1,512 cr (FY21) → ₹18,622 cr (FY26), while revenue grew 2.66× to ₹1,97,793 cr

18.4 → 18.6%
Operating (EBITDA) margin, FY21 → FY26
2.0 → 9.4%
Net margin, FY21 → FY26

Bear case · caveatFY21 was abnormal: a ₹2,190 cr SsangYong loss and write-downs. Measured from FY21’s ₹4,609 cr before one-offs, owners’ profit grew roughly 3.7× (an estimate).

Materials took 10.4 more points of revenue, yet net margin rose

Change in each line as a share of revenue, FY21 → FY26, percentage points

Raised the net marginLowered it

Why · inflation and mix

Materials rose faster than sales

Commodity inflation, plus a shift to the material-heavy auto business, whose share of segment revenue grew from 34% to 58%.

Materials: 51.7% → 62.1% of sales

Why · scale

Fixed costs spread over more output

Employee cost grew 10.3% a year, half revenue’s 21.6% pace. Fixed costs fell from 24.8% to 18.3% of sales.

Economies of scale

Why · clean-up

Credit losses eased, loss-makers exited

Expected credit losses fell 37% (₹4,140 cr → ₹2,596 cr). M&M exited loss-makers such as GenZe and Peugeot Motocycles.

Return on equity: 4.4% → 20.1%

The economics

Fixed vs variable costs: variable materials rose, fixed costs shrank as a share, and the two roughly cancelled out. The profit gain came below operating profit: lower interest, fewer one-offs, and exits.

Fit: clear on costs; profit gain below EBITDA

PAT includes minority interest. Source: M&M Integrated Annual Reports FY22 and FY26; audited FY21 results pack.

Market watch · Comparison of the four firms

Faster sales growth did not mean higher margins.

Eternal grew sales fastest and kept the thinnest margin. ITC grew slowest and kept the widest, about 27 paise of profit on every rupee of sales.

SymbolSeriesSales FY21 (₹ cr)Sales FY26 (₹ cr)Sales growthNet profit FY26 (₹ cr)Net margin FY21 → FY26Strategy
ETERNALEQ1,99454,364▲ 27.3×366▲ −40.9% → 0.7%Revenue maximisation
PAYTMEQ2,8028,437▲ 3.0×552▲ −60.7% → 6.5%Cost minimisation
ITCEQ49,27378,868▲ 1.6×21,018▼ 27.2% → 26.6%Profit through margin and mix
M&MEQ74,2781,97,793▲ 2.66×18,622▲ 2.0% → 9.4%Costs falling unevenly

Sales growth, FY21 → FY26

Multiple of FY21 sales

Net margin, FY21 → FY26

Hollow dot FY21, filled dot FY26 (%)

EternalPaytmITCM&M
ObjectiveRevenue maximisationCost minimisationProfit maximisation through margin and mixCosts falling unevenly
How costs movedGrew slower than sales in FY23–FY25, then jumped in FY26 once Blinkit owned its stockRose to an ₹11,645 cr peak in FY24, then fell 26.8% to ₹8,521 crRose 60%, in step with sales; fell 1.4% in FY24Materials 51.7% → 62.1% of sales; staff, overheads and credit losses fell as a share
Net profit−₹816 cr → ₹366 cr−₹1,701 cr → ₹552 cr₹13,383 cr → ₹21,018 cr₹1,512 cr → ₹18,622 cr
Main driverBlinkit scale-up, food-delivery growth, FY26 accounting changeLower ESOP cost (41% of the cut), processing fees (23%), staff and marketing cuts (about 30%)High-margin cigarettes carry profit; low-margin agri trade swings salesExits, smaller lending share, normalised credit losses, fixed costs spread over more output
Economic ideaBaumol’s modelLeast-cost production, X-inefficiency, operating leverageMR = MC, price-inelastic demand, diversificationFixed vs variable costs, economies of scale
How well it fitsGood but imperfectGood for FY24–FY26 onlyStrong in FY24, weaker over five yearsClear on costs; profit gain came below EBITDA

15:30 IST · Closing bell · Conclusion

Profit remains the final test.

Each strategy lasted only while profit stayed above a level owners would accept. Four lessons for reading company accounts:

1

Sales growth alone does not create profit

Eternal’s sales rose 27-fold, yet it kept only 0.7 paise of every rupee as net profit in FY26.

2

Read cost cuts carefully

The largest single saving at Paytm, 41% of the total, was a non-cash fall in stock-option costs.

3

Diversification steadies profit, but pricing power has limits

ITC’s profit fell in H1 FY27 after the February 2026 excise increase.

4

A cost can fall as a share of sales while rising in rupees

At M&M, only credit losses and interest outside the lending arm fell in rupee terms.

Podcast · 10 min

Dalal Street Decoded

The whole presentation as a market show, with hosts Tara and Aman.

Limits: accounting changes (Blinkit’s inventory model, the ITC Hotels demerger, SsangYong’s exit) and one-off items make some years hard to compare, so we flagged them. Textbook models simplify: every firm here mixed more than one objective.

Sources

Where our figures come from

Five-year data: Screener.in consolidated statements for all four companies, as of 16 November 2026, cross-checked against audited filings, annual reports and Moneycontrol. All figures in ₹ crore; FY26 means April 2025 to March 2026.

Eternal

  • Q4FY26 shareholders’ letter and audited FY26 results (28 Apr 2026)
  • Annual Report FY2025-26
  • Shareholders’ letters Q4FY23–Q4FY25
  • Apparel Resources: quick-commerce order shares

Paytm

  • One 97 Communications Annual Reports 2021-22 to 2025-26
  • Earnings releases Q4 FY24, Q4 FY26, Q2 FY27
  • RBI press release (16 Feb 2024)
  • Business Today (16 Apr 2025)

ITC

  • Consolidated results FY24, FY25 (Hotels demerger note) and FY26
  • Report and Accounts 2022
  • ICICI Direct Q4FY25 result update
  • 5paisa (B&K Securities, InCred estimates)

M&M

  • Integrated Annual Report 2025-26 (pp. 393, 434, 435, 471)
  • Q4 FY21 full-year results pack
  • Integrated Annual Report 2021-22
  • Results Q4 F26 and Q2 F27
09:00 Pre-open IST · 01/09← → chapters · F full screen